Leave a Comment | Posted by on July 28, 2009
Me on my soap box
Posted in: History
In the old days, people wanting attention would bring a soap box into town, and they’d stand on it to make a speech. Seems kind of silly in these days of YouTube, not to mention microphones and amplifiers, but everyone still knows what it means. And so, up on my proverbial soap box I go for a little speechifyin’.
I put together a harmless little video slide show featuring pictures of our summer so far, and legally purchased a song that seemed appropriate for it, adding it as the video soundtrack in my little amateur production. While attempting to upload my video on a popular social networking site which shall remain nameless, I received a “copyright infringement” notice. My video was removed, and I was threatened with legal action if I tried to upload the video again.
I thought that was kind of harsh.
Apparently the song that I purchased legally from iTunes can’t be used as a video soundtrack since I don’t own the rights to it. A record label does. Even when videos are set to “private” meant to be seen by only friends, they are either taken down after the fact, or prevented from being uploaded completely.
I am all for artists getting their fair share, my business is promoting music after all, but this seems a bit crazy to me. Who, exactly, is benefiting from hearing a cool song used as background music to my slide show? The artist. Someone caring enough to watch the video may be inspired to buy the CD or download the track themselves if they like it. I paid for the song, I’m not offering the MP3 as a free download for anyone to steal, I’m certainly not making any money by using the song, so what is the harm? Wouldn’t that constitute Fair Use of the song?
Nope.
It amazes me that something as simple and innocuous as this can be construed as illegal activity, but lawyers and litigators rule the roost these days.
As I step down from my soap box, I wonder if these types of things were even debated in the days of soap box speeches.
“The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers.” –William Shakespeare, Henry VI, written 1590.
Guess so…
–Brian







